Free Printable Thanksgiving Would You Rather Cards

Created by Print & Mingle

Seasonal games · Would you rather · 4 pages

24 original Thanksgiving would you rather cards with funny, gentle choices, colorful printable PDFs, and fair pair-play rules.

A choice game that fits around Thanksgiving dinner

These Thanksgiving would you rather cards turn a spare quarter hour into a shared conversation. Every prompt offers two playful options rather than asking someone to reveal private information or defend a serious opinion. The 24 choices include imaginary dinner settings, paper decorations, surprising menus, and friendly fantasy animals. Guests can simply choose an option or explain their reasoning. This is useful when people arrive at different times: nobody needs a backstory, a particular family tradition, or knowledge of holiday trivia to join the next question. Keep the game seated while food is being served and pause whenever the host needs attention.

What the four-page pack contains

Each PDF has four illustrated pages with six numbered cards on each page, giving you 24 original choices. A4 and US Letter contain the same questions, so download the paper size your printer uses. Print one pack for one table, cut the cards apart, and place them in a shallow bowl. There is no answer key because preferences are the point. You do not need to print a copy for each guest. For two separate tables, use two complete sets so neither group must wait. Keep the card numbers visible when trimming; they help you find a favorite without rereading everything.

Start with a simple round

Explain that the first option is A and the second is B. Read one card slowly, leave a few seconds for thinking, then invite everyone to show one finger for A or two for B. A spoken answer or pointing is equally acceptable. Ask two willing people why they chose differently, then change the reader. For the treehouse-or-train question, one person might enjoy the view while another likes the idea of a moving dinner. Both answers fit. Nobody must persuade anyone else, and passing needs no explanation. Use six cards for a short round before deciding whether the table wants more.

An optional pair challenge with equal chances

If your group wants points, make pairs and give every pair the same six questions. Each person writes A or B privately, then both reveal together. A matching pair earns one point; a mismatch earns none. Partners should not discuss their choices until after revealing. Rotate who reads, but do not change partners during the six-question round. The maximum score is six, and tied pairs share the win. This avoids extra sudden-death questions giving one pair a different challenge. Someone who prefers not to compete can help read cards, or everyone can return to the conversation version without keeping scores.

Keep the choices easy to hear and comfortable to answer

Read both options again if someone misses part of a prompt; speed is not part of this game. A host can describe unfamiliar objects, such as a paper scroll, before answers are chosen. Younger children may draw their choice on scrap paper instead of explaining it aloud. For a guest who communicates differently, offer a written A/B response or let a trusted partner read their selection. Skip a food-related card if it feels awkward for your group. The activity imagines meals and decorations; it does not ask anyone to eat something, spend money, or perform a physical challenge.

Printing, timing, and a good stopping point

Choose actual size or 100 percent in your printer settings and print a single test page first. Check that the card borders are visible before printing the remaining pages. Ordinary paper is enough for one gathering; use compatible light cardstock if you want sturdier cards. Allow around a minute for a question and brief discussion, with longer pauses if the stories are enjoyable. There is no obligation to use the whole pack. Before dessert is cleared, ask each person to nominate one card for next year, then store the cards in an envelope away from food spills.

Choose the next activity by the mood of the table

For an open-ended discussion without two fixed choices, use the Thanksgiving conversation cards. If everyone would rather draw than speak, switch to a few sheets of scrap paper and invite them to sketch their chosen option from this pack without scoring. For a quiet independent activity, the Thanksgiving word search offers a different pace. Do not schedule all the games back to back. One short activity that guests enjoy is more useful than a long program they feel obliged to finish. Save the unused cards for another visit or a smaller group.